Easy2Siksha.com
GNDU Question Paper-2021
Bachelor of Commerce
(B.Com) 3
rd
Semester
COMPANY LAWS
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks: 50
Note: Attempt five questions in all, selecting at least one question from each section. The
fifth question may be attempted from any section. All questions carry equal marks.
SECTION-A
1. Explain fully the Doctrine of ultra vires in relation to companies. What are the liabilities
of a company and its agents for ultra vires acts?
2. Discuss the different types of companies which may be incorporated under the
Companies Act.
SECTION-B
2. State and explain the procedure to call an annual general meeting.
3. Write a note on the provisions of the Company Law as regards issue and
allotment of shares.
SECTION-C
4. Write notes on:
(a) Dis-qualifications of Directors
Easy2Siksha.com
(b) Managerial Remuneration.
5.Explain the grounds on which the Tribunal would consider it just and equitable to wind
up a company.
SECTION-D
7. Write a detailed note on National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).
8. Explain in detail the salient features of Limited Liability Partnership (LLP).
Easy2Siksha.com
GNDU Answer Paper-2021
Bachelor of Commerce
(B.Com) 3
rd
Semester
COMPANY LAWS
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks: 50
Note: Attempt five questions in all, selecting at least one question from each section. The
fifth question may be attempted from any section. All questions carry equal marks.
SECTION-A
1. Explain fully the Doctrine of ultra vires in relation to companies. What are the liabilities
of a company and its agents for ultra vires acts?
Ans: A Different Beginning…
Imagine a ship setting sail from the port of Mumbai. The captain has a map — not just any
map, but one officially approved by the ship’s owners. This map clearly marks the
destinations the ship is allowed to visit. The crew, the passengers, and even the cargo
suppliers all trust that the captain will follow this map.
Now, suppose the captain decides, on a whim, to sail to a completely unlisted island — one
that’s not on the approved route. Even if the weather is perfect and the journey is
profitable, the captain has acted beyond his authority. In the world of company law, this is
exactly what we call “ultra vires” — Latin for “beyond the powers”.
1. What Is the Doctrine of Ultra Vires?
In company law, the Doctrine of Ultra Vires says that a company can only do what is within
the powers given to it by its Memorandum of Association (MOA).
• If an act is within the objects clause of the MOA, it is intra vires (within powers) and
valid.
• If an act is outside those objects, it is ultra vires (beyond powers) and void — even if
all shareholders agree to it.
Easy2Siksha.com
This doctrine protects shareholders and creditors by ensuring the company’s funds are used
only for authorised purposes.
2. Why Does This Doctrine Exist?
Think of the MOA as the company’s “constitution” — it tells the world what the company is
formed to do.
• For shareholders: It ensures their money is used only for the purposes they agreed
to when investing.
• For creditors: It ensures the company’s assets are not diverted into risky or
unrelated ventures.
• For the public: It provides transparency about the company’s scope of activities.
3. Key Features of the Doctrine
1. Rigid Boundaries: Acts beyond the MOA are void and cannot be ratified, even by
unanimous shareholder consent.
2. Constructive Notice: Outsiders dealing with the company are deemed to know its
MOA — they can’t claim ignorance.
3. Absolute Protection: It safeguards investors and creditors from misuse of funds.
4. Examples to Make It Real
• If a company’s MOA says it is formed to run a chain of restaurants, and it decides to
start a real estate business, that’s ultra vires.
• If a textile manufacturing company uses its funds to speculate in the stock market
without such power in its MOA, that’s ultra vires.
Even if these ventures make a profit, the acts are void in law.
5. Liabilities for Ultra Vires Acts
When a company or its agents (directors, officers) commit an ultra vires act, the law assigns
certain liabilities.
A. Liability of the Company
• No Legal Effect: The company is not bound by ultra vires contracts — they are void
ab initio (void from the beginning).
• Use of Funds: If company funds are used for an ultra vires purpose, shareholders can
get an injunction to stop it.
• Restitution: If the company has received property or money under an ultra vires
contract, it must return it (if possible).
B. Liability of Directors
Easy2Siksha.com
Directors are like the ship’s crew — they must steer within the authorised route.
• Personal Liability: If they authorise an ultra vires act, they may be personally liable
to compensate the company for any loss.
• Breach of Duty: They have a fiduciary duty to act within the company’s powers.
Breaching this duty can lead to legal action by shareholders.
C. Liability of Officers/Agents
• If an officer enters into an ultra vires contract on behalf of the company, they may be
personally liable to the third party for breach of warranty of authority.
D. Liability Towards Outsiders
• Outsiders cannot enforce an ultra vires contract against the company.
• However, if money or property was transferred under such a contract, they may
recover it if it is still identifiable.
6. Landmark Case — Ashbury Railway Carriage & Iron Co. Ltd. v. Riche (1875)
Facts: The company’s MOA allowed it to make and sell railway carriages. The directors
contracted to finance the construction of a railway line in Belgium — an activity not
mentioned in the MOA.
Held: The House of Lords held the contract was ultra vires and void. It could not be ratified,
even by unanimous shareholder approval.
This case cemented the principle that ultra vires acts are void and cannot be made valid by
consent.
7. How Modern Law Has Softened the Doctrine
In many countries, including India under the Companies Act, 2013, the doctrine’s rigidity has
been reduced:
• Companies can have very wide objects clauses.
• Amendments to the MOA are easier, allowing companies to expand their scope
legally.
• Still, acts beyond the MOA remain void unless the MOA is amended first.
8. A Simple Illustration
Let’s say GreenLeaf Ltd. is incorporated to manufacture organic fertilisers.
• Intra vires act: Buying new machinery for fertiliser production.
• Ultra vires act: Opening a luxury hotel chain without amending the MOA.
If the directors sign a hotel construction contract:
Easy2Siksha.com
• The contract is void against the company.
• Shareholders can sue to stop the project.
• Directors may have to personally bear any losses.
9. Why This Still Matters
Even with modern flexibility, the doctrine teaches an important lesson:
• A company is a legal person with defined powers.
• Those who manage it must respect those limits.
• Investors and creditors rely on those limits for their protection.
10. Wrapping It Up Like a Story
Think back to our ship. The map (MOA) is there for a reason — to keep the voyage safe,
predictable, and fair to everyone who has a stake in it. If the captain sails off to uncharted
waters without authority, the journey may be exciting, but it’s also unlawful.
The Doctrine of Ultra Vires is simply the law’s way of saying: “Stick to the map you promised
to follow — or face the consequences.”
2. Discuss the different types of companies which may be incorporated under the
Companies Act.
Ans: A Fresh Beginning…
It’s a warm afternoon in Delhi, and you’re standing in front of a huge exhibition ground. A
colourful banner flutters above the gate:
“The Great Corporate Fair – Meet Every Kind of Company!”
Inside, there are rows of pavilions, each representing a different type of company you can
form under the Companies Act. Some are grand and open to the public, others are small and
exclusive, and a few are so specialised that you’d miss them if you didn’t know where to
look.
You grab a map and step inside. Let’s take this tour together.
1. First Stop – The Liability Lane
Here, companies are grouped by how much their owners (members) are personally
responsible if things go wrong.
a) Company Limited by Shares
• What it means: Members’ liability is limited to the unpaid amount on their shares.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Example: If you bought shares worth ₹10,000 and paid ₹8,000, you can only be
asked for the remaining ₹2,000 if the company winds up.
• Why it’s popular: This is the most common form — safe, predictable, and investor-
friendly.
• In the fair: This pavilion is buzzing with activity — it’s the busiest stall because most
businesses choose this route.
b) Company Limited by Guarantee
• What it means: Members promise to contribute a fixed sum (guarantee) if the
company is wound up.
• Common use: Non-profits, clubs, charities.
• Example: A music society where each member guarantees ₹500 in case of closure.
• In the fair: This stall has posters of cultural events, charity drives, and community
projects.
c) Unlimited Company
• What it means: Members have unlimited liability — personal assets can be used to
pay company debts.
• Why rare: High risk, so few choose it.
• In the fair: This stall is quiet, with a big warning sign: “Enter at Your Own Risk.”
2. Second Stop – The Membership Market
Here, companies are grouped by how many people can be part of them.
a) One Person Company (OPC)
• What it means: A single person is the sole member and shareholder.
• Purpose: Encourages solo entrepreneurs with limited liability.
• Special feature: Must nominate someone to take over in case of death/incapacity.
• In the fair: A cosy, single-room stall with one chair — but a big sign saying “Dream
Big.”
b) Private Company
• Members: Minimum 2, maximum 200.
• Restrictions: Cannot freely transfer shares; cannot invite the public to invest.
• In the fair: A gated stall — you need an invitation to enter.
c) Public Company
• Members: Minimum 7, no maximum limit.
• Freedom: Can invite the public to buy shares; shares are freely transferable.
• In the fair: A huge open-air stage with banners inviting everyone to join.
Easy2Siksha.com
3. Third Stop – The Control Corner
Here, companies are grouped by who controls whom.
a) Holding Company
• What it means: A company that controls another company (subsidiary) by owning
more than 50% of its shares or controlling its board.
• In the fair: A tall tower with smaller buildings connected to it.
b) Subsidiary Company
• What it means: Controlled by a holding company.
• In the fair: Smaller stalls under the shadow of the big tower.
4. Fourth Stop – The Capital Court
Here, companies differ in how they raise money.
a) Listed Company
• What it means: Shares are listed on a recognised stock exchange.
• Benefit: Can raise capital from the public easily.
• In the fair: A brightly lit stall with a stock ticker running across the top.
b) Unlisted Company
• What it means: Shares are not listed; capital is raised privately.
• In the fair: A quieter stall with “By Invitation Only” written on the door.
5. Fifth Stop – The Purpose Plaza
Here, companies are grouped by why they exist.
a) For-Profit Companies
• Aim: Earn profits for shareholders.
• Most commercial enterprises fall here.
• In the fair: Stalls selling products, services, and investment opportunities.
b) Not-for-Profit Companies (Section 8 Companies in India)
• Formed for charitable, educational, cultural, or social purposes.
• Profits, if any, are reinvested in the company’s objectives.
• In the fair: A warm, welcoming stall with free books, art displays, and community
project boards.
Easy2Siksha.com
6. Special Attractions
Before leaving, you notice some unique stalls:
• Government Company: At least 51% owned by the government.
• Foreign Company: Incorporated outside India but operating in India.
• Small Company: Private company with limited paid-up capital and turnover.
• Producer Company: Formed by farmers/producers for mutual benefit.
Why This Tour Matters
By the time you leave the fair, you realise that knowing these types of companies is like
knowing the layout of a city — it tells you:
• How each company is managed
• How it raises money
• What risks members face
• What legal rules apply
A Story to Wrap It Up
As you step out of the Corporate Fair, you think: Every stall here — from the tiny OPC booth
to the towering public company stage — exists because the Companies Act allows it. The Act
is like the city planner, ensuring each company has a clear purpose, structure, and set of
rules.
Whether you’re an investor, entrepreneur, or just curious, understanding these types means
you can navigate the corporate world with confidence — and maybe even set up your own
stall in this grand fair one day.
SECTION-B
2. State and explain the procedure to call an annual general meeting.
Ans: A Fresh Beginning…
It’s the end of the financial year, and the headquarters of Sunrise Industries Ltd. is buzzing
like a beehive. The reception is stacked with files, the boardroom smells faintly of fresh
coffee, and the company secretary is pacing with a checklist in hand.
Why the rush? Because it’s time for the Annual General Meeting (AGM) — the one day in
the year when the company’s owners (shareholders) and its managers (directors) meet face-
to-face to review the year gone by, approve key decisions, and set the tone for the future.
Easy2Siksha.com
Calling an AGM isn’t just about picking a date and sending a few emails. Under the
Companies Act, 2013, it’s a carefully choreographed process — like planning a wedding
where every step is dictated by tradition and law.
Let’s walk through the procedure step-by-step, as if we’re shadowing the company secretary
on this important mission.
1. Understanding the Legal Backdrop
Before we dive into the “how,” let’s remember the “why.”
• Who must hold an AGM? Every public company must hold an AGM each year.
Private companies generally don’t have to, unless their Articles of Association say
otherwise.
• Timing rules:
o First AGM: Within 9 months from the end of the first financial year (and if
held within that time, no need for another in the same year).
o Subsequent AGMs: Within 6 months from the end of the financial year, but
not more than 15 months between two AGMs.
• Purpose: Present financial statements, declare dividends, appoint/reappoint
directors and auditors, and discuss other shareholder matters.
2. Step-by-Step Story of Calling an AGM
Step 1: Board Meeting – The Kick-off
Our company secretary, Ms. Kavita, first calls a Board Meeting.
• Why? Because the board must approve the date, time, and venue of the AGM, and
authorise the notice to be sent.
• Agenda items at this meeting:
1. Fix the date, time, and place of the AGM.
2. Approve the draft notice and agenda.
3. Authorise a director or the secretary to issue the notice.
Scene: The directors sit around the polished table, flipping through the proposed agenda.
One director suggests a Saturday afternoon so more shareholders can attend. Another
insists on a central city location. After some debate, the date is fixed: 15th September, 3:00
PM, at the company auditorium.
Step 2: Drafting the Notice – The Invitation
The AGM notice is like a wedding card — it must be clear, formal, and sent in time. Contents
of the notice (Section 101 of the Act):
• Day, date, time, and venue of the meeting.
• Statement of business to be transacted (ordinary and special).
Easy2Siksha.com
• Accompanied by an Explanatory Statement for special business (Section 102).
Ordinary business usually includes:
1. Approval of financial statements.
2. Declaration of dividend.
3. Appointment/reappointment of directors.
4. Appointment/reappointment of auditors and fixing their remuneration.
Special business could be:
• Alteration of Articles of Association.
• Issue of bonus shares.
• Approval of mergers, etc.
Step 3: Sending the Notice – The Countdown Begins
• Minimum notice period: 21 clear days before the meeting (excluding the day of
sending and the day of the meeting).
• Who gets it?
1. All members (shareholders).
2. Directors.
3. Auditors.
• How? By hand delivery, post, or electronic means (email).
Scene: Kavita double-checks the mailing list. She knows that if even one eligible shareholder
doesn’t get the notice, the meeting could be challenged. The notices go out — some by
courier, some by email — and the clock starts ticking.
Step 4: Preparing for the Day – The Logistics
In the weeks before the AGM:
• The finance team finalises the audited financial statements.
• The seating arrangement is planned.
• The projector is tested for the presentation.
• Copies of the annual report are printed and kept ready.
Scene: The auditorium is set up with nameplates for directors in the front row, a podium for
the chairman, and a registration desk at the entrance.
Step 5: The AGM Day – Showtime
On the day:
1. Quorum check: As per Section 103, the minimum number of members must be
present (varies with company size).
Easy2Siksha.com
2. Chairman’s address: The meeting is called to order.
3. Agenda items taken up: Ordinary business first, then special business.
4. Voting: By show of hands, electronic voting, or poll, as applicable.
5. Recording minutes: Every decision is noted for the official record.
Scene: The chairman greets the shareholders, thanks them for their trust, and walks them
through the year’s highlights. Questions are taken, votes are cast, and resolutions are
passed.
Step 6: After the Meeting – Wrapping Up
• Minutes: Drafted within 30 days and signed by the chairman.
• Filing with Registrar: Certain resolutions (special resolutions, auditor appointments,
etc.) must be filed with the Registrar of Companies in prescribed forms (like MGT-7,
AOC-4).
Scene: Kavita stays back after the meeting, ensuring every resolution is correctly recorded
and statutory filings are scheduled.
3. Why This Procedure Matters
The AGM is more than a legal formality — it’s the company’s annual “report card day.”
• For shareholders: A chance to question, approve, or reject management decisions.
• For directors: An opportunity to build trust and transparency.
• For the company: A legal requirement that, if ignored, can lead to penalties.
Closing the Story
As the sun sets on 15th September, the AGM of Sunrise Industries Ltd. is officially over.
Shareholders leave with a sense of clarity, directors with renewed mandates, and Kavita
with the satisfaction of a job well done.
The procedure may seem like a checklist on paper, but in practice, it’s a carefully timed
dance — one that keeps the company’s relationship with its owners healthy, transparent,
and legally sound.
3. Write a note on the provisions of the Company Law as regards issue and
allotment of shares.
Ans: A Fresh Beginning…
It’s a bright Monday morning at Emerald Tech Ltd. The boardroom is unusually full —
directors, the company secretary, and a few senior managers are gathered around a long
mahogany table.
Easy2Siksha.com
Why? Because the company is ready to raise capital for its ambitious new project — a state-
of-the-art manufacturing plant. And in the corporate world, raising capital often means one
thing: issuing and allotting shares.
But here’s the twist — they can’t just start selling shares like lemonade at a street stall. The
Companies Act, 2013 lays down a precise, step-by-step legal dance for how shares can be
issued and allotted. Miss a step, and the whole performance could be declared invalid.
Let’s walk through this story, step by step, so you can see exactly how the law works in
action.
1. Understanding the Basics
Before we dive into the procedure, let’s get our definitions straight:
• Issue of shares: Offering shares to potential investors (public, existing shareholders,
employees, etc.).
• Allotment of shares: The formal acceptance by the company of an investor’s
application, creating a binding contract between the two.
Think of it like sending out wedding invitations (issue) and then confirming the guest list
(allotment).
2. Legal Provisions Governing Issue of Shares
The Companies Act, 2013, along with the SEBI regulations (for listed companies), governs
how shares can be issued. The main types of share issues are:
a) Public Issue
• Who can do it? Public companies.
• Forms:
1. Initial Public Offer (IPO) – first time shares are offered to the public.
2. Further Public Offer (FPO) – additional shares offered after the IPO.
• Process: Requires issuing a prospectus, complying with SEBI guidelines, and getting
stock exchange approvals.
b) Rights Issue (Section 62)
• Offered to existing shareholders in proportion to their current holdings.
• Notice must be given, usually allowing at least 15–30 days to accept.
• Shareholders can renounce their rights in favour of others.
c) Private Placement (Section 42)
• Shares offered to a select group of identified persons (max 200 in a financial year,
excluding QIBs and employees).
Easy2Siksha.com
• Requires a private placement offer letter and filing with the Registrar.
d) Preferential Allotment
• Shares issued to specific persons at a pre-decided price, often used for strategic
investors.
e) Bonus Issue
• Free shares given to existing shareholders, capitalising company reserves.
3. The Story of Emerald Tech’s Share Issue
Emerald Tech decides on a rights issue to fund its new plant. Here’s how the law guides
their journey:
Step 1: Board Meeting – The Green Light
The directors meet to:
• Approve the type of issue (rights issue).
• Fix the price, ratio, and record date.
• Approve the draft offer letter.
• Authorise the company secretary to send notices.
Scene: The chairman taps the table, “We’ll offer 1 new share for every 4 held, at ₹120 each.
Record date: 1st October.”
Step 2: Drafting and Sending the Offer Letter
• Contents: Number of shares offered, price, time limit for acceptance, and
renunciation rights.
• Mode: Sent to all eligible shareholders by post or electronic means.
• Timeframe: Minimum 15 days, maximum 30 days to respond.
Scene: Kavita, the company secretary, ensures every shareholder’s name and address is
double-checked. She knows a missed notice could cause legal trouble.
Step 3: Receiving Applications and Money
Shareholders send in application forms with payment. Some take up their full entitlement,
some renounce in favour of friends, and a few ignore the offer.
Step 4: Allotment of Shares
Once the offer period closes:
• The board meets again to approve allotment.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Allotment must be done within 60 days of receiving application money (as per
Section 42 for private placement; rights issues follow similar prompt timelines).
• If not allotted, money must be refunded within 15 days thereafter, or interest is
payable.
Scene: The boardroom is quieter this time. The finance head confirms the total applications.
The resolution for allotment is passed unanimously.
Step 5: Filing with the Registrar
• Return of Allotment (Form PAS-3) must be filed within 30 days of allotment,
containing details of allottees.
• This ensures transparency and public record.
Step 6: Issuing Share Certificates
• Certificates must be issued within 2 months from the date of allotment (Section 56).
• For demat shares, credit is given to the investor’s account.
Scene: Share certificates are printed on thick, embossed paper — a tangible proof of
ownership.
4. Key Legal Safeguards
The law builds in protections to ensure fairness and prevent abuse:
• Minimum subscription: In public issues, at least 90% of the issue must be
subscribed, or money is refunded.
• Application money: Minimum 5% of nominal value must be received with the
application.
• No allotment without approval: In certain cases, stock exchange or SEBI approval is
mandatory.
• Penalty for default: Failure to comply can lead to fines for the company and officers.
5. Why This Procedure Matters
Issuing and allotting shares isn’t just a fundraising exercise — it’s about:
• Protecting shareholder rights.
• Maintaining investor confidence.
• Ensuring transparency in ownership changes.
• Complying with statutory obligations to avoid penalties.
Closing the Story
Easy2Siksha.com
By the end of this journey, Emerald Tech has successfully raised the funds it needs — and
every step has been by the book. Shareholders are happy, the new plant is on track, and the
company’s legal record is spotless.
The moral? In company law, issuing and allotting shares is like hosting a grand event — the
invitations, guest confirmations, seating arrangements, and thank-you notes all have to be
perfectly timed and executed. Do it right, and you win trust, capital, and compliance in one
go.
SECTION-C
4. Write notes on:
(a) Dis-qualifications of Directors
(b) Managerial Remuneration.
Ans: A Fresh Beginning…
Imagine a grand theatre called Corporate India. On its stage, the main actors are the
Directors — the people who steer the company’s story. They make the big decisions, set the
vision, and lead the cast (employees, shareholders, stakeholders) toward the climax of
success.
But here’s the twist: Not everyone can be a director, and even those who make it to the
stage can’t just decide their own paycheque. The Companies Act, 2013 is like the theatre’s
rulebook — it decides who is allowed to act and how much they can be paid.
Let’s pull back the curtain and watch this play unfold in two acts.
ACT I – Disqualifications of Directors
(Section 164 of the Companies Act, 2013)
The first act is all about who cannot be on stage — the law’s way of ensuring that only
trustworthy, capable people get to direct the company’s story.
Scene 1: The Basic Disqualifications (Section 164(1))
These apply to any person who wants to be a director in any company. The law says:
“You’re out if…”
Easy2Siksha.com
1. Unsound Mind – If a court has declared you of unsound mind and the declaration is
still in force. Analogy: Like a pilot who’s lost their medical clearance — you can’t be
trusted to fly the plane.
2. Undischarged Insolvent – If you’re officially bankrupt and haven’t been discharged.
Analogy: If you can’t manage your own finances, how can you manage a company’s?
3. Convicted of an Offence – If you’ve been convicted by a court and sentenced to
imprisonment for at least 6 months (and 5 years must pass after the sentence ends if
it was for 7 years or more). Analogy: A criminal record is like a permanent red flag on
your résumé.
4. Non-payment of Calls on Shares – If you haven’t paid money you owe on shares for
more than 6 months. Analogy: If you don’t pay your own dues, you can’t be trusted
with others’ money.
5. Failure to Comply with Director Identification Number (DIN) Requirements – If you
don’t have a valid DIN.
Scene 2: Company-Specific Disqualifications (Section 164(2))
These apply if you’re already a director in a company that has failed in its duties. You’re
disqualified if the company you’re in charge of has:
• Not filed financial statements or annual returns for 3 continuous years.
• Failed to repay deposits, interest, or declared dividends for over a year.
Consequence: You can’t be a director in any company for 5 years.
Scene 3: Special Disqualifications
The company’s Articles of Association can add extra conditions — like a theatre adding its
own audition rules.
Why This Matters: These rules protect the company’s “audience” — the shareholders and
public — from directors who might misuse their role. It’s about keeping the stage safe and
the performance credible.
ACT II – Managerial Remuneration
(Sections 197, 198, Schedule V of the Companies Act, 2013)
Now that we know who can act, the second act is about how much they can be paid. In our
theatre analogy, this is the part where the producer decides the actors’ salaries — but here,
the producer is the law.
Scene 1: Who Does This Apply To?
Managerial remuneration rules cover:
• Managing Director (MD)
Easy2Siksha.com
• Whole-time Director (WTD)
• Part-time Director
• Manager
Scene 2: The Golden Rule – Overall Limit
For a public company, the total managerial remuneration in any financial year cannot
exceed 11% of the net profits of the company (calculated as per Section 198).
This 11% is like the budget cap for the lead actors’ salaries.
Scene 3: Individual Limits
Within that 11%:
• MD/WTD/Manager: Max 5% of net profits (if only one such person).
• If more than one MD/WTD/Manager: Max 10% combined.
• Other directors: Max 1% (if there is an MD/WTD/Manager) or 3% (if there isn’t).
Scene 4: When Profits Are Low or Nil
Sometimes the play doesn’t sell enough tickets — the company has inadequate or no
profits. In such cases, Schedule V allows payment of remuneration within prescribed limits
based on the company’s effective capital, without Central Government approval. If they
want to pay more, they need shareholder approval by special resolution.
Scene 5: Approval Process
• Board approval is always needed.
• Shareholder approval by ordinary or special resolution (depending on the case).
• In some cases, Central Government approval (though much less common after 2017
amendments).
Scene 6: Exclusions
Certain payments don’t count towards the 11% cap:
• Sitting fees for attending meetings (up to prescribed limits).
• Reimbursement of expenses.
• Commission to non-executive directors (within limits).
Why This Matters: These rules prevent directors from overpaying themselves at the cost of
shareholders. It’s about fairness, transparency, and aligning pay with performance.
Closing the Story
As the curtain falls on our corporate theatre, the message is clear:
Easy2Siksha.com
• Act I ensures only the right people get to direct the show.
• Act II ensures they’re paid fairly, without draining the theatre’s coffers.
The Companies Act is both the casting director and the paymaster — keeping the
performance ethical, sustainable, and worthy of applause from the audience that matters
most: the shareholders.
5.Explain the grounds on which the Tribunal would consider it just and equitable to wind
up a company.
Ans: A Fresh Beginning…
The scene opens in a grand courtroom. On one side sits Blue Horizon Ltd., a company that
once sparkled with promise — tall glass offices, ambitious projects, and smiling
shareholders. On the other side sits a group of frustrated investors, creditors, and even
some directors.
The air is tense. The question before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) is not
about profits or losses, but something deeper:
“Should this company’s story end here? Is it just and equitable to wind it up?”
This phrase — just and equitable — is the law’s way of saying: “Is it fair, reasonable, and in
the best interest of everyone to close this company down?”
Under Section 271(e) of the Companies Act, 2013, the Tribunal has the power to order
winding up on this ground. But it’s not used lightly — it’s like the final curtain call in a play,
only drawn when continuing the show would be unfair or impossible.
1. Understanding the ‘Just and Equitable’ Ground
Unlike other winding-up grounds (like inability to pay debts), this one is broad and flexible.
It allows the Tribunal to look beyond numbers and into the real circumstances —
relationships, trust, purpose, and fairness.
It’s not about punishing the company; it’s about recognising when keeping it alive would
cause more harm than good.
2. Common Situations Where It Applies
Over the years, courts have identified certain recurring situations where winding up is
considered just and equitable. Let’s walk through them like chapters in Blue Horizon Ltd.’s
story.
A. Deadlock in Management
Easy2Siksha.com
Scene: The boardroom is split into two camps. Every decision — from hiring a manager to
approving a budget — ends in a tie. No one can move forward.
• This often happens in companies with equal shareholding and no casting vote
provision.
• The deadlock paralyses the company’s operations.
• The Tribunal may step in to end the stalemate by winding up.
Analogy: It’s like a car with two drivers fighting over the steering wheel — the car isn’t going
anywhere, and sooner or later, it will crash.
B. Loss of Substratum (Main Purpose Gone)
Scene: Blue Horizon was formed to develop a luxury resort on a specific beachfront. Years
later, the government acquires that land for a naval base. The main project — the very
reason for the company’s existence — is gone.
• If the company’s primary object becomes impossible to achieve, it loses its
“substratum” (foundation).
• Continuing operations would be pointless.
Analogy: It’s like a theatre troupe whose only play has been banned — they have no script
left to perform.
C. Loss of Mutual Trust in Quasi-Partnership Companies
Scene: Blue Horizon started as a small, closely-held company between three friends. Over
time, personal disputes turned bitter. Accusations fly, meetings turn hostile, and the spirit of
mutual confidence is gone.
• In small private companies resembling partnerships, trust is the glue.
• If that trust breaks down irreparably, the Tribunal may wind up the company.
Analogy: Imagine a band where the members can’t stand to be in the same room — the
music dies.
D. Oppression of Minority Shareholders
Scene: The majority shareholders in Blue Horizon pass resolutions that consistently sideline
the minority — diverting profits, excluding them from management, and altering articles to
their disadvantage.
• If such oppression is severe and there’s no other effective remedy, winding up may
be ordered.
• However, the Tribunal often prefers other remedies under Sections 241–242 before
winding up.
Easy2Siksha.com
E. Persistent Losses and No Hope of Revival
Scene: Year after year, Blue Horizon posts losses. Creditors are restless, employees are
leaving, and no viable turnaround plan exists.
• If the business model is broken beyond repair, winding up may be the fairest option.
• This overlaps with “inability to pay debts” but focuses on fairness rather than strict
insolvency.
F. Fraudulent or Illegal Purpose
Scene: Evidence emerges that Blue Horizon was set up mainly to launder money.
• If the company’s very existence is tainted by fraud or illegality, the Tribunal can wind
it up in the public interest.
3. The Tribunal’s Approach
The Tribunal doesn’t grant this order casually. It considers:
• Is there an alternative remedy? (e.g., buyout of shares, management change)
• Will winding up harm more than help?
• Is the petition genuine or a pressure tactic?
The guiding principle: Would a reasonable, fair-minded person think it’s right to close this
company in these circumstances?
4. Landmark Case References
• Ebrahimi v. Westbourne Galleries Ltd. (1973): UK case that shaped Indian law —
recognised loss of mutual trust in quasi-partnership companies as a ground.
• Hind Overseas Pvt. Ltd. v. Raghunath Prasad Jhunjhunwalla (1976): Indian Supreme
Court stressed that winding up is a last resort.
5. Why This Ground is Special
Most winding-up grounds are black-and-white — either you can pay your debts or you can’t.
But “just and equitable” is shades of grey. It gives the Tribunal the flexibility to deliver
justice in unique situations where rigid rules would fail.
Closing the Story
Back in the Tribunal, the judge leans forward. After hearing the evidence — the deadlocked
board, the lost project, the broken trust — the decision is clear.
“It is just and equitable to wind up Blue Horizon Ltd.”
Easy2Siksha.com
The gavel falls. The company’s story ends, not as a punishment, but as an act of fairness —
freeing shareholders from a hopeless situation and allowing resources to be put to better
use.
And that’s the essence of this ground: sometimes, ending the play is the kindest thing you
can do for everyone in the theatre.
SECTION-D
7. Write a detailed note on National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).
Ans: A Fresh Beginning…
Picture this: It’s a crisp Monday morning in New Delhi. Inside a modern, glass-fronted
building, the corridors are buzzing. Lawyers in black coats walk briskly, clutching thick files.
Company directors wait anxiously in the lobby. A large brass plaque at the entrance reads:
“National Company Law Tribunal”
This is no ordinary court. It’s a specialised stage where the dramas of the corporate world
are played out — from shareholder disputes to insolvency battles, from mergers to winding-
up orders.
The NCLT is like the “corporate doctor” of India’s legal system — diagnosing problems in
companies, prescribing remedies, and sometimes performing the painful surgery of shutting
a company down.
Let’s step inside and understand what it is, why it exists, and how it works.
1. Birth of the NCLT – Why It Was Created
Before the NCLT came into being, company-related cases were scattered across different
forums:
• Company Law Board (CLB) handled company disputes.
• High Courts dealt with winding-up petitions.
• Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) handled sick companies.
• Debt Recovery Tribunals (DRTs) dealt with some financial matters.
This meant delays, duplication, and confusion.
The Justice Eradi Committee recommended a single, unified body to handle all corporate
matters. The idea was to bring speed, expertise, and consistency to corporate justice.
Easy2Siksha.com
Thus, under the Companies Act, 2013, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) was
established in 2016, replacing the CLB and taking over many powers from High Courts and
other bodies.
2. What Exactly is the NCLT?
• It’s a quasi-judicial body — meaning it has powers like a court but specialises in
company law matters.
• It operates under the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA).
• Its orders can be appealed to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal
(NCLAT), and from there to the Supreme Court on points of law.
3. Structure of the NCLT
The NCLT isn’t just one courtroom in Delhi — it has benches across India to make access
easier.
Composition:
• President: Usually a retired High Court judge.
• Judicial Members: Persons with legal/judicial background.
• Technical Members: Experts in company law, finance, accountancy, management,
etc.
This mix ensures that decisions are not just legally sound but also commercially practical.
4. Powers and Jurisdiction – What Can the NCLT Do?
Think of the NCLT as a “one-stop shop” for corporate disputes and regulatory approvals. Its
powers include:
A. Company Law Matters
• Incorporation disputes: Questions about the legality of a company’s formation.
• Transfer of shares: Rectification of the register of members.
• Oppression and mismanagement: Protecting minority shareholders from unfair
treatment by the majority (Sections 241–242 of the Companies Act).
• Winding up of companies: On various grounds, including “just and equitable”
reasons.
• Compromise and arrangements: Approving mergers, demergers, and restructuring
schemes.
B. Insolvency and Bankruptcy
Under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016, the NCLT is the adjudicating
authority for:
Easy2Siksha.com
• Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP): When a company defaults on debt,
creditors or the company itself can approach NCLT to resolve it.
• Liquidation: If resolution fails, NCLT orders liquidation.
• Fast-track insolvency: For small companies and start-ups.
C. Other Powers
• Investigating company affairs on application by the government or members.
• Hearing grievances related to refusal to transfer securities.
• Depositor protection cases.
• Conversion of public companies into private companies and vice versa.
5. Procedure – How Does the NCLT Work?
Let’s follow a fictional case to make it real.
Case: Lotus Textiles Pvt. Ltd. is accused by minority shareholders of siphoning funds.
1. Filing of Petition: The aggrieved shareholders file a petition under Section 241 for
oppression and mismanagement.
2. Admission: NCLT examines if the petition is complete and within jurisdiction.
3. Notices: Issued to the company and other respondents.
4. Hearing: Both sides present evidence, documents, and arguments.
5. Order: NCLT may order changes in management, reversal of unfair decisions, or even
winding up if necessary.
6. Appeal: If unhappy, parties can appeal to NCLAT within 45 days.
6. Why the NCLT is Important
• Specialisation: Judges and technical members understand corporate complexities.
• Speed: Designed to reduce delays compared to regular courts.
• Comprehensive jurisdiction: One forum for multiple corporate issues.
• Investor confidence: A strong dispute resolution system attracts investment.
7. Landmark Roles Played by NCLT
• IBC Cases: NCLT has been central in resolving big insolvency cases like Essar Steel, Jet
Airways, and Bhushan Steel.
• Minority Protection: It has intervened in cases where majority shareholders acted
unfairly.
• Corporate Restructuring: Approved major mergers and demergers, ensuring
compliance with law and fairness to stakeholders.
8. Difference Between NCLT and NCLAT
Feature
NCLT
NCLAT
Easy2Siksha.com
Role
First-level adjudication
Appellate body
Appeals to
NCLAT
Supreme Court
Composition
President, Judicial & Technical
Members
Chairperson, Judicial & Technical
Members
9. Limitations and Challenges
• Backlog: Despite its design for speed, NCLT faces heavy caseloads.
• Infrastructure: Some benches lack adequate facilities.
• Consistency: Different benches may interpret laws differently, leading to appeals.
Closing the Story
As you step out of the NCLT building in our story, you realise it’s more than just a tribunal —
it’s the heartbeat of corporate justice in India.
Here, the fate of companies is decided: some are given a second chance through
restructuring, some are merged into stronger entities, and some are respectfully laid to rest.
The NCLT is where law meets business, where fairness meets finance, and where the
corporate world’s most important stories find their final script.
8. Explain in detail the salient features of Limited Liability Partnership (LLP).
Ans: A Different Kind of Beginning…
Imagine you and your best friend are sitting in a small café, sketching out your dream
business on a tissue napkin. You’re excited — but also nervous. You’ve heard horror stories
of partnerships where one partner’s mistake ruined the other’s life savings.
Then, a friendly lawyer at the next table leans over and says: "Why don’t you two form an
LLP? It’s like a partnership, but with a safety shield."
That’s how many entrepreneurs first meet the concept of Limited Liability Partnership —
not in a textbook, but in the real world, as a solution to a very human fear: “What if my
partner’s mistake costs me everything?”
1. What is an LLP?
A Limited Liability Partnership is a hybrid business structure that blends the flexibility of a
partnership with the protection of limited liability usually found in companies.
Easy2Siksha.com
It was introduced in India through the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008, and became
operational in 2009.
Think of it as a “best of both worlds” model:
• Like a partnership: easy to run, flexible internal rules, no heavy corporate formalities.
• Like a company: partners are not personally liable for the firm’s debts beyond their
agreed contribution.
2. Why LLP Was Needed
Before LLPs, entrepreneurs had two main choices:
• Partnership Firm: Flexible, but partners had unlimited liability. If the firm failed,
personal assets could be seized.
• Private Company: Limited liability, but more compliance, rigid structure, and higher
costs.
The LLP was born to give professionals, start-ups, and small businesses a middle path —
safety without suffocating rules.
3. Salient Features of LLP – The Story Version
Let’s walk through the key features as if we’re meeting the LLP in person.
A. Separate Legal Entity – The LLP Has Its Own Identity
In the eyes of the law, an LLP is like a separate “person.”
• It can own property, sign contracts, sue, and be sued in its own name.
• Your personal identity is separate from the LLP’s identity.
Story angle: If your LLP borrows money and can’t repay, creditors can go after the LLP’s
assets — but not your personal house or car (unless you’ve given a personal guarantee).
B. Limited Liability – The Safety Shield
Partners’ liability is limited to the amount they agreed to contribute.
• If you invested ₹5 lakh, that’s the maximum you can lose in normal circumstances.
• You’re not responsible for your partner’s negligence or misconduct.
Analogy: It’s like wearing a helmet while riding a bike — accidents may happen, but your
head is protected.
C. Perpetual Succession – LLP Never “Dies”
Partners may come and go, but the LLP continues.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Death, retirement, or insolvency of a partner doesn’t dissolve the LLP.
• This gives stability and confidence to clients and investors.
D. Minimum Two Partners – But No Upper Limit
• You need at least two partners to start.
• There’s no maximum limit — you can have as many as you like.
• At least two Designated Partners must be individuals, and one must be a resident in
India.
E. Designated Partners – The Responsible Captains
Designated Partners are like the captains of the ship:
• They ensure compliance with the law.
• They file returns, maintain records, and face penalties if rules are broken.
• Their details are registered with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs.
F. Flexible Internal Management
• The relationship between partners is governed by an LLP Agreement — a private
contract.
• You can decide profit-sharing ratios, decision-making processes, and dispute
resolution methods.
• No rigid company law provisions on board meetings or resolutions.
G. Lower Compliance Burden
Compared to companies, LLPs have:
• No requirement for annual general meetings.
• Simpler annual filings (Statement of Accounts & Solvency, Annual Return).
• No complex share capital rules.
H. Taxation Benefits
• LLPs are taxed like partnership firms, not companies.
• No dividend distribution tax (DDT).
• Profits are taxed in the hands of the LLP, not the partners.
I. Easy to Form and Operate
• Registration is online through the MCA portal.
• Fewer formalities than a company.
• Ideal for professionals (lawyers, architects, consultants) and small businesses.
J. Conversion Options
Easy2Siksha.com
Existing partnership firms, private companies, and unlisted public companies can convert
into LLPs — keeping assets and liabilities intact.
4. LLP vs. Traditional Partnership vs. Company
Feature
Partnership Firm
LLP
Private Company
Legal Status
Not separate
Separate legal entity
Separate legal entity
Liability
Unlimited
Limited
Limited
Compliance
Low
Low–Moderate
High
Ownership Transfer
Difficult
Possible with agreement
Possible via shares
Perpetual Succession
No
Yes
Yes
5. Real-Life Example
Imagine Amit and Priya, two interior designers.
• In a traditional partnership, if Priya accidentally breaches a client contract, Amit’s
personal savings could be at risk.
• In an LLP, Amit’s liability is limited to his agreed contribution. Priya’s mistake doesn’t
wipe out Amit’s personal wealth.
This protection encourages professionals to collaborate without fear.
6. Limitations of LLP
While LLPs are great, they’re not perfect:
• Cannot raise equity capital from the public.
• Some investors prefer companies for their shareholding structure.
• Still requires compliance with MCA filings.
• Not suitable for businesses aiming for large-scale public funding.
7. Quick Recap Table
Salient Feature
Why It Matters
Separate Legal Entity
LLP can own property, sue, be sued
Limited Liability
Protects personal assets
Perpetual Succession
Business continues despite partner changes
Flexible Agreement
Partners decide internal rules
Lower Compliance
Saves time and cost
Tax Benefits
No DDT, taxed like partnership
Conversion Options
Easy shift from other structures
Closing the Story
Easy2Siksha.com
As you and your friend leave that café, you realise the LLP is like a trustworthy business
partner who promises: "I’ll give you freedom to run your business your way, but I’ll also
stand between you and financial disaster."
That’s why LLPs have become the go-to choice for professionals, start-ups, and small
businesses in India — they offer the freedom of a partnership with the protection of a
company, all wrapped in a structure that’s easy to understand, easy to run, and built for the
realities of modern business.
“This paper has been carefully prepared for educational purposes. If you notice any
mistakes or have suggestions, feel free to share your feedback.”
